comp.lang.ada
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed
From: world!srctran@uunet.uu.net  (Gregory Aharonian)
Subject: ARPA,Air Force,Navy publicly brag about a great C++ code
Date: 2 Sep 93 14:17:26 GMT	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <CCqD13.ED6@world.std.com> (raw)

    From the August 30 issue of Government Computer News, page 68 (somewhat
condensed)

              DOD trains soldiers with virtual battlefield

	NPSNET is the first interactive virtual environment to be networked
	based according to developers of a battlefield simulation coded
	by programmers at the Naval Postgraduate School and the Air Force
	Institute of Technology.

	Using DoD's DIS protocols, NPSNet is available to 150 DoD sites
	via a gateway to the Defense Simulation Internet.  [Stuff about
	how players interact in real time with great graphics, problems
	in writing code to handle these effects].

	NPSNet has as one purpose to be placed in the public domain a
	visual simulation shell and related network routines to give
	defense laboratories and contractors a low-cost entry for
	further virtual reality.

	NPSNet, sponsored by ARPA, has cost the government $750,000 per
	year.  NPS and AFIT have distributed 50 copies of the C++ source
	code to DoD sites, saving the government $50,000 to $80,000 per
	copy.

	NPSNet, was shown off to at Siggraph to spark interest and
	suggestions from computer graphics experts around the world,
	said the program head, Lt. Col. David Neyland.
==============================================================================

     As great an effort as this is, and as much as I like the programming
efforts going on at NPS and AFIT (two fine educational institutions), stuff
like this is truly horrible for helping Ada succeed.  It sends out virtually
every wrong signal to the non-Mandated world that the DoD doesn't believe
its own beliefs about Ada.

     First, if you can't say something good about an Ada program to the
press, don't say something better about a C++ program.  It makes the all
encompassing Ada Mandate look even more idiotic than it is.  Too many
non-Mandated people are picking up on the fact that all they seem to
see in good news coming out of the DoD about programming rarely deals
with Ada.  The majority of success stories in GCN over the last three
years have all been about DoD units using C/C++ - not Ada.

     Second, people in the non-Mandated world once again are seeing another
success story with software with ARPA involvement that does not involve Ada.
Many non-Mandated people wonder why the leading software agency of the DoD,
ARPA, refuses to have anything to do with Ada.  You can't praise ARPA to
the high heavens, and then allow it to dis Ada.

     Third, it provides indirect proof that whatever is going on in the
STARS program is a complete waste of money.  It seems when ever the DoD
manages to creat a good thing, which NPSNet is, it goes out of its way to
expose it to the public to benefit the public and to get feedback from
the public (the comments of Lt. Col. Neyland).  One can only assume that
when the DoD has created a mess, it does its best to hide it from the public
as much as possible, i.e., STARS.

     Fourth, this article sends a signal that for state of the art
programming activities, virtual reality, interactive graphics, distributed
processing, networking and communications, that Ada is not the language to
use.  When I suggest that the Mandated world appear at trade shows, I
meant appear with Ada stuff.

     It is stuff like this that is killing Ada, not my attitude.
-- 
**************************************************************************
 Greg Aharonian                                      srctran@world.std.com
 Source Translation & Optimization                            617-489-3727
 P.O. Box 404, Belmont, MA 02178

             reply	other threads:[~1993-09-02 14:17 UTC|newest]

Thread overview: 4+ messages / expand[flat|nested]  mbox.gz  Atom feed  top
1993-09-02 14:17 Gregory Aharonian [this message]
  -- strict thread matches above, loose matches on Subject: below --
1993-09-04  0:45 ARPA,Air Force,Navy publicly brag about a great C++ code Robert Dewar
1993-09-06  1:22 Harry Erwin
1993-09-07  3:16 Robert Dewar
replies disabled

This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox