Re: [ANN] UXStrings package available (UXS_20210207).

[Blady <p.p11@orange.fr>]

Le 11/02/2021 à 09:19, Emmanuel Briot a écrit :
> There is clearly a need here, given the number of implementations out there. I had also implemented GNATCOLL.Strings 4 years ago, with similar goals to yours:
>    - unicode support (via generic formal parameters and traits packages, so you can use UTF8, UTF16,... internally)
>    - unbounded strings (with optional copy-on-write)
>    - task safety (using traits to chose what kind of counter to use)
>    - performance (small-string optimization: no memory alloc for strings of 18 characters or less)
>    - extended API (all missing subprograms from Ada.Strings.Unbounded)
>    - extensive testing
> 
> I must admit I am not sure why AdaCore chose to write VSS instead of improving one of their string implementations (ada.strings.unbounded, gnatcoll.strings,...)
> My initial idea had been that it would be possible to provide a nice generic package, highly configurable via traits, on top of which we could reimplement ada.strings.unbounded,
> ada.strings.bounded,...) but I left AdaCore before that could be accomplished.

I'm preparing some optimization when the character set is reduced thus 
the internal structure will adapt to the actual content.
But the memory management is bad, the set of API is very basic.
I'll be glad that you can help.

> I took a look at VSS and find the API confusing. Your API UXString is at least much clearer (if lacking doc at the moment :-)

Some documentation has been added in a form of comments of each API:
https://github.com/Blady-Com/UXStrings/commit/2bee0ab61841f5e319533b67d2747dda66aa9bd7#diff-90cde6014508061fab9d62e58b327815a954859e5da8a1fd655fa4e5854e7ac5

> I am hoping that the work on Alire (Ada package manager) will ultimately help us find one implementation that is good enough for everyone,
> and could ultimately become part of the language.

Alire registration is on the way:
https://github.com/alire-project/alire-index/pull/250

Pascal.